Ranked values of the abundance discrepancy O2+ abundance discrepancy 1000100101 Hii regions Planetary nebulae Planetary nebulae with close binary central stars median adf: 2.2 80th percentile: 5

[save figure]

This is a list of 207 literature values of the abundance discrepancy factor for O2+, which is hopefully complete. Click on a heading to sort the table, and an attribute to highlight the relevant nebulae. Objects are identified on the figure when you hover the mouse over their bar. The data on fluxes, velocities, morphologies, sizes and distances was collected with the help of several other attendees at the WorkPLANS meeting in Leiden in February 2016.

ADF:
Object type:
Morphology:

ObjectDiscrepancyTypeReferencePNGRADecDiameter (arcseconds)MorphologylogF(Hβ)I(4363)I(5007)Vexp ([OIII])Vexp ([NII])Distance (kpc)
M 2-39 0.4PN2007MNRAS.381..669W008.1-04.718:22:01.10-24:10:40.193.2E-12.1313.0537.09.02 +- 2.79
SDS J1253-03120.79HII2014MNRAS.443..624E
NGC 5461 1.23HII2009ApJ...700..654E
NGC 7027 1.3PN2005A%26A...442..249Z084.9-03.421:07:01.7042:14:09.4915.6x12.0B-10.1221.523.50.94 +- 0.27
Orion 1.3HII1998MNRAS.295..401E05:35:17.30-05:23:28
30 Dor 1.38HII2017MNRAS.467.3759T
NGC 6572 1.38PN2005ApJS..157..371R034.6+11.818:12:06.4006:51:12.1714B-9.829.0399.016.016.01.46 +- 0.42
M 1-20 1.4PN2007MNRAS.381..669W006.1+08.317:28:57.60-19:15:53.822.5x2.3E-11.935.0326.07.88 +- 2.31
M 2-23 1.4PN2007MNRAS.381..669W002.2-02.718:01:42.60-28:25:43.908.5E-11.578.01078.05.92 +- 1.92
NGC 6369 1.4PN2013A%26A...558A.122G002.4+05.817:29:20.40-23:45:34.2433.0x32.7E-11.328.01484.041.60.91 +- 0.28
Orion 1.4HII2007ApJ...670..457G05:35:17.30-05:23:28
Hen 2-96 1.41PN2018MNRAS.473.4476G309.0+00.813:42:36.1-61:22:29.17
NGC 6790 1.44PN2005ApJS..157..371R037.8-06.319:22:57.0001:30:46.444.4x3.4B-10.9013.01152.015.04.20 +- 1.22
NGC 2867-11.49PN2009A%26A...496..139G278.1-05.909 21 25.38-58 18 40.9
IC 4846 1.5PN2007MNRAS.381..669W027.6-09.619:16:28.20-09:02:36.563B-11.346.0369.013.17.13 +- 2.01
NGC 5253 B1.5HII2007ApJ...656..168L13:39:56.00-31:38:25.80
NGC 6572 1.5PN2004MNRAS.353..953T034.6+11.818:12:06.4006:51:12.1714B-9.829.0399.016.016.01.46 +- 0.42
Hen 3-13571.51PN2017ApJ...838...71O331.3-12.117:16:21.08-59:29:23.3
IC2111 1.51HII2017MNRAS.467.3759T
NGC 6891 1.52PN2005MNRAS.362..424W054.1-12.120:15:08.8012:42:15.6213.5x12.7E-10.6515.07.02.88 +- 0.82
NGC 5447 1.54HII2009ApJ...700..654E
NGC 6572S1.54PN2005ApJS..157..371R034.6+11.818:12:06.4006:51:12.1714B-9.829.0399.016.016.01.46 +- 0.42
IC 132 1.58HII2016MNRAS.458.1866T
LMC N11B 1.58HII2017MNRAS.467.3759T
NGC 1714 1.58HII2017MNRAS.467.3759T
NGC 5315 1.58PN2017MNRAS.471.1341M309.1-04.313:53:57.00-66:30:50.9410.7x9.2B-10.423.0840.040.037.52.03 +- 0.59
Tol 1924-4161.58HII2014MNRAS.443..624E
30 Dor 1.6HII2003ApJ...584..735P05:38:42.40-69:06:03.36
Cn 1-5 1.6PN2007MNRAS.381..669W002.2-09.418:29:11.70-31:29:59.217.4x7.4B-11.213.0268.018.04.99 +- 1.42
Hu 1-2 1.6PN2004MNRAS.353.1251L086.5-08.821:33:08.3039:38:09.568.3B5.06 +- 1.44
M 1-61 1.6PN2013A%26A...558A.122G019.4-05.318:45:55.10-14:27:37.941.8R-11.434.0914.06.61 +- 2.02
NGC 5189 1.6PNb2013A%26A...558A.122G307.2-03.413:33:33.00-65:58:26.69163.4x108.2B-10.5213.01428.036.024.50.78 +- 0.22
NGC 5471 1.6HII2002ApJ...581..241E14:04:28.6054:23:52
NGC 604 1.6HII2002ApJ...581..241E01:34:32.1030:47:01
NGC 6572 1.6PN2004MNRAS.353.1251L034.6+11.818:12:06.4006:51:12.1714B-9.829.0399.016.016.01.46 +- 0.42
Hen 2-1581.61PN2018MNRAS.473.4476G327.8-06.116:23:30.6-58:19:22.66
Lin 49* 1.62PN2016MNRAS.462...12O00:43:53.887-72:55:14.79
POX 4 1.62HII2014MNRAS.443..624E
Wray 16-4231.64PN2015MNRAS.452.4070O006.8-19.819:22:10.63-31:30:38.7
Hen 2-1181.7PN2007MNRAS.381..669W327.5+13.315:06:13.70-42:59:56.471.3S-11.7011.01190.015.19 +- 4.43
NGC 6565 1.7PN2007MNRAS.381..669W003.5-04.618:11:52.50-28:10:42.2810.8x10.5E-11.227.01340.014.522.03.18 +- 0.92
NGC 6790 1.7PN2004MNRAS.353.1251L037.8-06.319:22:57.0001:30:46.444.4x3.4B-10.9013.01152.015.04.20 +- 1.22
Pe 1-1 1.7PN2013A%26A...558A.122G285.4+01.510:38:27.60-56:47:06.403B5.39 +- 1.82
NGC 6822 V1.73HII2014MNRAS.443..624E
M 31-K 932 1.74HII2009ApJ...700..654E
H 4-1 1.75PN2013ApJ...778..146O049.3+88.112:59:27.7727:38:10.5
IC 4776 1.75PNb2017MNRAS.471.3529S002.0-13.418:45:50.72-33:20:34.217.0x8.0B4.44 +-1.27
NGC 2867-21.77PN2009A%26A...496..139G278.1-05.909 21 25.38-58 18 40.9
NGC 300 R201.77HII2016MNRAS.458.1866T
M 1-25 1.8PN2013A%26A...558A.122G004.9+04.917:38:30.30-22:08:38.873.9E-11.92518.05.60 +- 1.90
MyCn18 1.8PN2004MNRAS.353..953T307.5-04.913:39:35.10-67:22:51.4617.3x9.8B2.75 +- 0.78
NGC 3576 1.8HII2003MNRAS.338..687T11:11:49.80-61:18:14
NGC 3576 1.8HII2007ApJ...670..457G11:11:49.80-61:18:14
NGC 3918 1.8PN2004MNRAS.353..953T294.6+04.711:50:17.70-57:10:56.8918.7x17.1B-10.0415.01667.024.226.51.55 +- 0.44
NGC 5253 A1.8HII2007ApJ...656..168L13:39:55.90-31:38:24
NGC 588 1.81HII2016MNRAS.458.1866T
NGC 604 1.81HII2009ApJ...700..654E
NGC 3918 1.85PN2015MNRAS.452.2606G294.6+04.711:50:17.70-57:10:56.8918.7x17.1B-10.0415.01667.024.226.51.55 +- 0.44
Cn 1-5 1.9PN2013A%26A...558A.122G002.2-09.418:29:11.70-31:29:59.217.4x7.4B-11.213.0268.018.04.99 +- 1.42
Hen 2-86 1.9PN2013A%26A...558A.122G300.7-02.012:30:30.40-64:52:05.593.2B-12.261070.04.62 +- 1.53
IC 4406 1.9PN2004MNRAS.353..953T319.6+15.714:22:26.20-44:09:02.4137.2B-10.747.01267.06.014.01.81 +- 0.51
M 2-4 1.9PN2007MNRAS.381..669W349.8+04.417:01:06.20-34:49:38.572.4E-11.84792.07.67 +- 2.29
NGC 3603 1.9HII2007ApJ...670..457G11:15:24.00-01:01:15.00
NGC 5253 C1.9HII2007ApJ...656..168L 13:39:56.02-31:38:27.89
NGC 5307 1.9PN2003ApJ...595..247R312.3+10.513:51:03.30-51:12:20.6318.8x12.9B-11.1816.01378.010.83.16 +- 0.90
NGC 5461 1.9HII2002ApJ...581..241E14:03:40.9654:19:02.40
NGC 6644 1.9PN2004MNRAS.353..953T008.3-07.318:32:34.60-25:07:44.004.4x4.3B-10.9912.0465.04.95 +- 1.45
NGC 6741 1.9PN2004MNRAS.353.1251L033.8-02.619:02:37.10-00:26:56.989.1x6.5E-11.3211.01274.023.021.53.29 +- 1.02
NGC 6822 V1.9HII2005ApJ...634.1056P083.5+12.719:44:56.20-14:47:51.29-9.986.0858.011.01.40 +- 0.40
NGC 6826 1.9PN2004MNRAS.353.1251L083.5+12.719:44:48.2050:31:30.3225E1.40 +- 0.40
PC 14 1.9PN2013A%26A...558A.122G336.2-06.917:06:14.80-52:30:00.407.2x5.1B5.97 +- 1.80
S311 1.9HII2007ApJ...670..457G07:52:18.50-26:25:41
NGC 23631.95HII2009ApJ...700..654E
NGC 456 1.95HII2017MNRAS.467.3759T
SMC N88A1.95HII2017MNRAS.467.3759T
M 1-61 2PN2007MNRAS.381..669W019.4-05.318:45:55.10-14:27:37.941.8R-11.434.0914.06.61 +- 2.02
M 17 2HII1999RMxAA..35...65E18:20:47.00-00:16:10.30
M 8 2HII1993ApJ...418..760P18:03:37.00-00:24:23.20
M 8 2HII2007ApJ...670..457G18:03:37.00-00:24:23.20
NGC 2403-VS 442.00HII2009ApJ...700..654E
NGC 5315 2PN2004MNRAS.353..953T309.1-04.313:53:57.00-66:30:50.9410.7x9.2B-10.423.0840.040.037.52.03 +- 0.59
NGC 6807 2PN2005MNRAS.362..424W042.9-06.919:34:33.5005:41:02.582.0x1.9R-11.48242.013.09.48 +- 2.70
NGC 7662 2PN2004MNRAS.353.1251L106.5-17.623:25:54.0042:32:05.0329.4E-9.9927.529.01.36 +- 0.38
Vy 2-1 2PN2007MNRAS.381..669W007.0-06.818:27:59.60-26:06:48.284E6.68 +- 1.91
LMC N44C 2.04HII2017MNRAS.467.3759T
NGC 300 R232.04HII2016MNRAS.458.1866T
NGC 6543S2.07PN2005ApJS..157..371R096.4+29.917:58:33.4066:37:58.8025.5B-9.6119.520.01.15 +- 0.32
H 1-35 2.1PN2007MNRAS.381..669W355.7-03.517:49:13.90-34:22:52.973B-11.45582.05.39 +- 1.66
M 17 2.1HII2003MNRAS.338..687T18:20:47.00-00:16:10.30
M 17 2.1HII2007ApJ...670..457G18:20:47.00-00:16:10.30
M 20 2.1HII2007ApJ...670..457G18:02:42.00-00:22:58.30
M 2-42 2.1PN2007MNRAS.381..669W008.2-04.818:22:32.10-24:09:27.613.8B-12.124.0929.0
Me 2-2 2.1PN2005MNRAS.362..424W100.0-08.722:31:43.7047:48:03.961.9B8.75 +- 2.48
NGC 5882 2.1PN2004MNRAS.353..953T327.8+10.015:16:49.90-45:38:58.6015.6x12.9B-10.374.01048.011.023.51.98 +- 0.56
M 1-31 2.11PN2018MNRAS.473.4476G006.4+02.017:52:41.4-22:21:56.84
NGC 300 R142.13HII2016MNRAS.458.1866T
M 1-74 2.14PN2005MNRAS.362..424W052.2-04.019:42:18.8015:09:08.245R6.82 +- 1.99
SMC N81 2.14HII2017MNRAS.467.3759T
NGC 595 2.18HII2009ApJ...700..654E
IC 3568 2.2PN2004MNRAS.353.1251L123.6+34.512:33:06.8082:33:50.2917R-10.8211.01095.07.82.72 +- 0.77
M 2-27 2.2PN2007MNRAS.381..669W359.9-04.518:03:52.60-31:17:46.542.5S-12.201070.06.26 +- 1.84
M 2-33 2.2PN2007MNRAS.381..669W002.0-06.218:15:06.50-30:15:32.904.9E-11.60605.08.19 +- 2.36
M 3-29 2.2PN2007MNRAS.381..669W004.0-11.118:39:25.80-30:40:36.709.7x8.6E-11.602.2599.07.06.66 +- 1.91
NGC 2363 2.2HII2002ApJ...581..241E07:28:29.8369:11:32.80
NGC 3242 2.2PN2004MNRAS.353..953T261.0+32.010:24:46.10-18:38:32.2431.5x30.7B-9.7911.0698.020.027.51.03 +- 0.29
NGC 6567 2.2PN2007MNRAS.381..669W011.7-00.618:13:45.10-19:04:33.677.2E-10.9310.01038.018.436.03.24 +- 0.94
SMC N66A2.24HII2017MNRAS.467.3759T
IC 5217 2.26PN2005MNRAS.362..424W100.6-05.422:23:55.7050:58:00.446.6E-11.1712.01219.017.528.04.61 +- 1.30
H1013 2.29HII2009ApJ...700..654E
Hen 2-73 2.29PN2018MNRAS.473.4476G296.3-03.011:48:38.2-65:08:37.32
H 1-42 2.3PN2007MNRAS.381..669W357.2-04.517:57:25.20-33:35:42.945.8S-11.706.01261.06.05 +- 1.73
M 2-6 2.3PN2007MNRAS.381..669W353.3+06.317:04:18.30-30:53:28.728E
M 3-15 2.3PN2013A%26A...558A.122G006.8+04.117:45:31.70-20:58:01.784.2B5.51 +- 1.69
NGC 6884 2.3PN2004MNRAS.353.1251L082.1+07.020:10:23.7046:27:39.536E-11.11985.023.03.22 +- 0.92
SMC N66 2.3HII2003MNRAS.338..687T00 59 27.40 -72 10 10.7
NGC 300 R22.34HII2016MNRAS.458.1866T
30 Dor 2.35HII2003MNRAS.338..687T05:38:42.40-69:06:03.36
H 1-50 2.37PN2018MNRAS.473.4476G
IC 4191 2.4PN2004MNRAS.353..953T304.5-04.813:08:47.30-67:38:37.685.3x4.5B-11.008.0567.012.03.93 +- 1.11
M 1-30 2.4PN2013A%26A...558A.122G355.9-04.217:52:58.90-34:38:22.993.5E-11.77153.06.49 +- 2.02
NGC 3132 2.4PN2004MNRAS.353..953T272.1+12.310:07:01.80-40:26:11.1159.9x45.6B-10.454.01021.014.721.01.12 +- 0.32
NGC 6720 2.4PN2004MNRAS.353.1251L063.1+13.918:53:35.1033:01:45.0176E-10.0813.01655.026.50.92 +- 0.26
M 2-31 2.42PN2018MNRAS.473.4476G006.0-03.618:13:16.0-25:30:04.97
NGC 6879 2.46PN2005MNRAS.362..424W057.2-08.920:10:26.7016:55:21.295R-11.585.0868.021.57.00 +- 2.05
NGC 6833 2.47PN2005MNRAS.362..424W082.5+11.319:49:46.6048:57:40.100.5B-11.259.0485.013.017.85 +- 5.06
NGC 6210 2.5PN2005ApJS..157..371R043.1+37.716:44:29.5023:47:59.5716.2B-10.096.0365.021.035.52.05 +- 0.58
PB 8 2.57PN2009A%26A...496..139G292.4+04.111 33 17.84-57 06 14.8
H 1-54 2.6PN2007MNRAS.381..669W002.1-04.218:07:07.20-29:13:06.354.8B-11.88436.08.17 +- 2.45
LMC N141 2.6PN2004MNRAS.353..953T05 25 26.022 -68 55 53.99
M 3-21 2.6PN2007MNRAS.381..669W355.1-06.918:02:32.30-36:39:10.942.8R-11.428.0521.07.73 +- 2.30
NGC 3125 2.63HII2014MNRAS.443..624E
NGC 5408 2.69HII2014MNRAS.443..624E
NGC 6803 2.71PN2005MNRAS.362..424W046.4-04.119:31:16.5010:03:21.895.4x5.1E-11.1822.01495.014.520.04.59 +- 1.37
NGC 6543 2.74PN2005ApJS..157..371R096.4+29.917:58:33.4066:37:58.8025.5B-9.6119.520.01.15 +- 0.32
M 1-60 2.75PN2018MNRAS.473.4476G019.7-04.518:43:38.1-13:44:48.62
M 1-33 2.77PN2018MNRAS.473.4476G013.1+04.117:58:58.8-15:32:14.78
M 16 2.8HII2007ApJ...670..457G18:18:48.00-00:13:48.40
SMC N87 2.8PN2004MNRAS.353..953T01 21 10.69 -73 14 34.8
H 1-40 2.88PN2018MNRAS.473.4476G359.7-02.617:55:36.1-30:33:32.08
Cn 2-1 2.9PN2007MNRAS.381..669W356.2-04.417:54:33.00-34:22:20.863S-11.639.0542.07.46 +- 2.16
H 1-50 2.9PN2007MNRAS.381..669W358.7-05.218:03:53.50-32:41:42.1410E-11.6812.01763.0
NGC 6818 2.9PN2004MNRAS.353..953T025.8-17.919:43:57.70-14:09:11.6624.7x24.7E-10.4813.0245.027.631.01.88 +- 0.53
IC 4846 2.91PN2005MNRAS.362..424W027.6-09.619:16:28.20-09:02:36.563B-11.346.0369.013.17.13 +- 2.01
Sp 4-1 2.94PN2005MNRAS.362..424W068.7+14.819:00:26.5038:21:07.99B
Hu 1-1 2.97PN2005MNRAS.362..424W119.6-06.100:28:15.6055:57:54.726.3E5.91 +- 1.67
K 648 2.99PN2015ApJS..217...22O065.0-27.321:29:59.4012:10:26.20
M 1-29 3PN2007MNRAS.381..669W359.1-01.717:50:18.00-30:34:54.917.6E-12.207.01627.03.32 +- 1.02
M 1-32 3PN2013A%26A...558A.122G011.9+04.217:56:20.00-16:29:03.959.1x8.0E-12.20398.03.56 +- 1.08
NGC 6543 3PN2004MNRAS.351.1026W096.4+29.917:58:33.4066:37:58.8025.5B-9.6119.520.01.15 +- 0.32
BoBn 1 3.05PN2010ApJ...723..658O108.4-76.100:37:16.03-13:42:58.6
NGC 6210 3.1PN2004MNRAS.353.1251L043.1+37.716:44:29.5023:47:59.5716.2B-10.096.0365.021.035.52.05 +- 0.58
IC 351 3.14PN2005MNRAS.362..424W159.0-15.103:47:33.0035:02:48.527E-11.4212.01230.015.05.73 +- 1.62
IC 1747 3.2PN2005MNRAS.362..424W130.2+01.301:57:35.8063:19:18.1213E-11.497.01352.027.53.08 +- 1.00
NGC 6620 3.2PN2007MNRAS.381..669W005.8-06.118:22:54.20-26:49:17.008R-11.736.01244.06.31 +- 1.81
NGC 7026 3.36PN2005MNRAS.362..424W089.0+00.321:06:18.6047:51:07.8514B-10.9038.052.51.67 +- 0.48
NGC 7027 3.58PN2005ApJS..157..371R084.9-03.421:07:01.7042:14:09.4915.6x12.0B-10.1221.523.50.94 +- 0.27
IC 4593 3.6PN2005ApJS..157..371R025.3+40.816:11:44.5412:04:17.06
NGC 6302 3.6PN2004MNRAS.353..953T349.5+01.017:13:44.40-37:06:12.8956.1B-10.5524.01354.08.00.64 +- 0.18
M 1-73 3.61PN2005MNRAS.362..424W051.9-03.819:41:09.3014:56:59.395B4.18 +- 1.27
Hb 4 3.7PN2013A%26A...558A.122G003.1+02.917:41:52.80-24:42:08.0611.1x6.8B-11.951444.023.02.88 +- 0.86
Hu 2-1 4PN2005MNRAS.362..424W051.4+09.618:49:47.6020:50:39.442.6B4.18 +- 1.18
Mrk 1271 4.16HII2014MNRAS.443..624E
M 3-34 4.23PN2005MNRAS.362..424W031.0-10.819:27:01.90-06:35:04.637.4x6.4E5.90 +- 1.69
M 3-7 4.4PN2007MNRAS.381..669W357.1+03.617:24:34.40-29:24:19.485.8S5.19 +- 1.53
LMC N11B 5-8HII2003MNRAS.338..687T04:56:51.50-66:24:25
M 2-36 5PN2001MNRAS.327..141L003.2-06.218:17:41.40-29:08:19.578.1R-11.20808.0
NGC 6720 5-10PN2001ApJ...558..145G063.1+13.918:53:35.1033:01:45.0176E-10.08579.026.50.92 +- 0.26
NGC 7009 5PN1995MNRAS.272..369L037.7-34.521:04:10.90-11:21:48.2428.0x22.0B-9.7818.0425.020.620.01.26 +- 0.36
NGC 7009 5PN2013MNRAS.429.2791F037.7-34.521:04:10.90-11:21:48.2428.0x22.0B-9.7818.0425.020.620.01.26 +- 0.36
H 1-41 5.1PN2007MNRAS.381..669W356.7-04.817:57:19.10-34:09:49.109.6E-11.70868.05.36 +- 1.56
DdDm 1 5.3PN2009ApJ...705..509O061.9+41.316:40:18.2038:42:19.91
NGC 2440 5.4PN2004MNRAS.353..953T234.8+02.407:41:55.40-18:12:32.7638.4B-10.5022.01790.022.51.29 +- 0.37
M 3-27 5.48PN2005MNRAS.362..424W043.3+11.618:27:48.3014:29:06.072.8x2.3R
Hen 2-2836PNb2018MNRAS.tmp.1786W355.7-03.017:47:49.43-34:08:05.15.0
Vy 1-2 6.17PN2005MNRAS.362..424W053.3+24.017:54:23.0027:59:57.984.6E8.13 +- 2.30
IC 4699 6.2PN2007MNRAS.381..669W348.0-13.818:18:32.00-45:59:01.7212.6x8.0E-11.6913.01240.010.06.29 +- 1.78
NGC 6439 6.2PN2007MNRAS.381..669W011.0+05.817:48:19.80-16:28:44.224.5E-11.688.01145.024.06.31 +- 2.07
Hen 2-1556.3PNb2015A%26A...580A..19J338.8+05.616:19:23.10-42:15:35.9616.9x14.5B-11.595.01215.02.85 +- 0.82
M 3-33 6.6PN2007MNRAS.381..669W009.6-10.618:48:12.10-25:28:52.397.4x7.3E-12.007.01090.07.50 +- 2.15
IC 2003 7.31PN2005MNRAS.362..424W161.2-14.803:56:22.0033:52:30.5810.0x8.1E-11.1912.0983.021.54.33 +- 1.22
Abell 63 8PNb2015ApJ...803...99C053.8-03.019:42:10.3017:05:14.3944.9B3.79 +- 1.12
NGC 6153 10PN2000MNRAS.312..585L341.8+05.416:31:30.50-40:15:12.6028.0x24.2E-10.841073.017.517.01.32 +- 0.38
Hen 2-16111PNb2015A%26A...580A..19J331.5-02.716:24:37.80-53:22:34.1416.3x9.7B-12.10377.03.85 +- 1.14
LMC N66 11PN2004MNRAS.353..953T05 36 20.718 -67 18 07.73
NGC 6153 11PN2016MNRAS.461.2818M341.8+05.416:31:30.50-40:15:12.6028.0x24.2E-10.841073.017.517.01.32 +- 0.38
DdDm 1 11.8PN2005MNRAS.362..424W061.9+41.316:40:18.2038:42:19.910.6S17.38 +- 5.04
Vy 2-2 11.8PN2005MNRAS.362..424W045.4-02.719:24:22.2009:53:56.653.1x2.6S4.12 +- 1.30
NGC 2022 16PN2004MNRAS.353..953T196.6-10.905:42:06.2009:05:10.7527.9x25.5E-11.1310.0755.026.02.60 +- 0.74
Hen 2-43616.3PN2011ApJ...729...39O004.8-22.719:32:06.71-34:12:57.50.6
M 2-24 17PN2003A%26A...404..545Z356.9-05.818:02:02.90-34:27:47.056.8
M 3-32 17.8PN2007MNRAS.381..669W009.4-09.818:44:43.10-25:21:33.848.1x6.8E-11.905.0773.07.30 +- 2.09
NGC 40 17.8PN2004MNRAS.353.1251L120.0+09.800:13:01.0072:31:19.0948B-10.6629.026.01.34 +- 0.38
NGC 6337 18PNb2018MNRAS.tmp.1786W349.3-01.117:22:15.67-38:29:01.847.6x46.5
NGC 6778 18PNb2016MNRAS.455.3263J034.5-06.719:18:24.90-01:35:47.4021.4x15.5B-11.166.01028.020.0252.79 +- 0.79
M 1-42 20PN2001MNRAS.327..141L002.7-04.818:11:05.00-28:58:59.3413.1x11.3B-11.622.2590.025.06.03.77 +- 1.21
M 1-42 22PN2016MNRAS.461.2818M002.7-04.818:11:05.00-28:58:59.3413.1x11.3B-11.622.2590.025.06.03.77 +- 1.21
NGC 6326 23PNb2018MNRAS.tmp.1786W338.1-08.317:20:46.25-51:45:15.1720.6x13.7
NGC 1501 32PN2004MNRAS.354..558E144.5+06.504:06:59.2060:55:14.3452E-11.28932.037.0
Fg 1 46PNb2018MNRAS.tmp.1786W290.5+07.911:28:36.20-52:56:04.5046.9
Ou 5 56PNb2015ApJ...803...99C086.9-03.421:14:20.0043:41:35.0248.0x36.0B6.49 +- 1.82
Pe 1-9 60PNb2018MNRAS.tmp.1786W005.0+03.017:45:36.89-23:02:26.6213.6x13.4
MPA 1759 62PNb2018MNRAS.tmp.1786W000.5-03.117:59:15.59-30:02:47.1525.0x18.0
Hf 2-2 70PNb2006MNRAS.368.1959L005.1-08.918:32:30.90-28:43:20.3921.7x21.7E4.24 +- 1.22
Hf 2-2 80PNb2016MNRAS.461.2818M005.1-08.918:32:30.90-28:43:20.3921.7x21.7E4.24 +- 1.22
Abell 58 90PN2008MNRAS.383.1639W037.5-05.119:18:20.5001:46:59.6344.7x33.7E5.68 +- 1.78
Abell 46 120PNb2015ApJ...803...99C055.4+16.018:31:18.7026:56:12.3463E2.67 +- 0.78
Abell 30 700PN2003MNRAS.340..253W208.5+33.208:46:53.5017:52:45.48127R3.11 +- 0.88